'Coates loan write-off a sign of commitment' - Maguirepublished at 17:00 GMT 3 March
'No John Coates, no party'
Stoke City reported a £60.8m profit in their latest accounts but the numbers should not look that good, according to football finance expert Kieran Maguire.
A "structural change" saw owner John Coates waive a £90.5m loan, dramatically changing the outlook of Stoke's end-of-year figures.
"A £60m profit was made - that really is driven by the fact the owner wrote off a £90m loss, if that wasn't the case it would look a lot worse," Maguire told BBC Radio Stoke.
"But there are some positives, there is more money coming through the door. The money coming in is good, the wage bill is a bit better - [it's] under control."
Maguire believes that Coates' loan write-off also has a positive outlook for the club's future beyond their accounts for the year, emphasising what it says about the owner's long-term plans.
"No John Coates, no party. He's a very benevolent owner, there is no doubt about that," Maguire said.
"If the owner's circumstances change or the owner's attitude changes, it can be problematic. The Coates family put in £46m of cash last year in the form of fresh shares which was very beneficial for the club.
"It's certainly a sign of ongoing commitment by John Coates - and also the fact the running a football club is an expensive hobby."
However, Maguire added that turning a profit because of their owner's generosity does not mean Stoke are set for a fruitful summer.
"I think the club will have to be cautious as far as this summer is concerned," he said.
"The reason for that is that the debt write-off is not included as part of your PSR [Profit and Sustainability Rules] calculations so you would have to look at it as -£30m rather than a positive of £60m.
"So the rumours of Kylian Mbappe seen wandering around an estate agent in Hanley are probably overstating the good news."
Listen to Maguire's full breakdown on BBC Sounds
Listen to more Stoke City content on BBC Sounds




























